VERDICT
In the administrative litigation
of Mr. xxx,
plaintiff,
Authorized representative:
Attorney Sven Adam,
Lange Geismarstraße 55, 37073 Göttingen,
against
the Kassel Savings Bank Association, represented by the Association Assembly,
Wolfsschlucht 9, 34117 Kassel,
Defendant,
Authorized representative:
HFK Rechtsanwälte,
Stephanstraße 31, 60313 Frankfurt am Main,
loaded:
1. xxx,
2. xxx,
3. xxx,
4. xxx,
5. xxx,
6. xxx,
7. xxx,
8. xxx,
because of savings bank law
The Administrative Court of Kassel – 4th Chamber – through
Presiding Judge at the Administrative Court xxx,
Judge at the Administrative Court xxx,
Judge xxx,
Lay Judge xxx,
Lay Judge xxx
Based on the oral hearing of January 23, 2019, the following judgment was rendered:
With the annulment of the resolution of the General Assembly of the Kassel Savings Bank Association of 1 September 2016 concerning the allocation of seats (page 9 of the minutes of the meeting of the General Assembly of the Kassel Savings Bank Association on 1 September 2016 dated 1 November 2016) and corresponding annulment of the appeal decision of the Kassel Savings Bank Association of 27 December 2016, the determination of the result of the allocation of seats with regard to the election of the four members of the Administrative Board from among the persons eligible to be elected to the City Council of the City of Kassel of 1 September 2016 is hereby annulled.
The defendant shall bear the costs of the proceedings.
The judgment is provisionally enforceable against security in the amount of 110% of the amount to be enforced, due to the costs.
The appeal is admitted.
FACTS
On September 1, 2016, the assembly of the Kassel Savings Bank's joint association elected a new board of directors, which, according to Section 31 of the Kassel Savings Bank's statutes, is to consist of four members from among those eligible for election to the Kassel district council and four members from among those eligible for election to the Kassel city council. The elections were conducted according to the principles of proportional representation, as stipulated in Section 55 of the Hessian Municipal Code (HGO).
The election result for the four members of the Administrative Board from among those eligible to be elected to the City Council of Kassel, which is the only result being challenged here, was determined by the election supervisor as follows:
Number of voting representatives of the
members of the association assembly: 48
Number of representatives of the members of the association assembly present today
: 47
Votes cast: 47
Invalid votes: 1
Valid votes: 46
The following votes were cast for the individual nominations:
CDU parliamentary group proposal: 10
; Joint proposal of the SPD and
Alliance 90/The Greens parliamentary groups: 26;
AfD parliamentary group proposal: 5;
Kassel Left parliamentary group proposal: 5
This results in the following seat distribution
: CDU: 1 seat;
Joint proposal of the SPD and
Alliance 90/The Greens parliamentary groups: 3 seats;
AfD: 0 seats;
Kassel Left: 0 seats
The General Assembly has thus elected the following individuals to the Administrative Board of the Kassel Savings Bank from among those eligible for election to the Kassel City Council:
Mr. Bernd-Peter Doose (CDU list),
Mr. Christian Geselle (SPD – Alliance 90/The Greens list)
, Dr. Günther Schnell (SPD – Alliance 90/The Greens
list), and Mr. Dieter Beig (SPD – Alliance 90/The Greens list).
To determine the outcome of this seat allocation, the election supervisor, as evidenced by the minutes of the meeting of the Kassel Savings Bank Association's general assembly on September 1, 2016, further explained that the joint list of candidates from the SPD and Alliance 90/The Greens had received an absolute majority of the votes. Applying the majority clause according to Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the Hessian Municipal Election Law (KVVG), the absolute majority of votes received must also be taken into account when allocating the seats. As a result, the joint list of candidates from the SPD and Alliance 90/The Greens will receive three seats instead of two. The drawing of lots for one seat between the AfD and the Kassel Left Party is therefore unnecessary.
After the election results were announced, the plaintiff, a member of the Zweckverband (special-purpose association) assembly and the candidate nominated by the Kasseler Linke (Kassel Left Party) faction, referred to a 2014 ruling by the Kassel Administrative Court, according to which the application of Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the German Banking Act (KWG) to supervisory board elections at savings banks was inadmissible and the seat allocation had therefore not been correctly determined. The election supervisor rejected this objection, and the Zweckverband assembly confirmed the allocation of seats for the election of the four supervisory board members from among those eligible for election to the Kassel City Council by a majority vote (see resolution, page 9 of the minutes of the meeting of the Zweckverband assembly of the Kassel Savings Banks Association on September 1, 2016, dated November 1, 2016).
The plaintiff filed an objection to the validity of the election and the determination of the election results with the election officer by letter dated September 9, 2016. By resolution dated December 1, 2016, the Zweckverband assembly rejected the plaintiff's objection and declared the elections and the determination of the election results valid.
On December 28, 2016, the plaintiff filed an election challenge lawsuit, based on various arguments.
In the oral proceedings, the plaintiff abandoned parts of his original argumentation and limited the "election challenge" to the determination of the election result with regard to the election of the four members from among those eligible to be elected to the city council of the city of Kassel.
He argues that applying Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the German Banking Act (KWG) contradicts the provisions of Section 23 of the Hessian Savings Bank Act (HSparkG). The Savings Bank Act, as a lex specialis, supersedes the catch-all provision of Section 7 Paragraph 2 of the Act on Intermunicipal Cooperation (KGG). Section 23 Paragraph 1 of the HSparkG refers solely to Section 22 Paragraph 3 of the KWG and not to Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the KWG. Furthermore, applying Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the KWG via Section 7 Paragraph 2 of the KGG would result in the majority clause applying to savings banks whose members of the supervisory board are elected by a special-purpose association assembly, but not to all other savings banks. This inconsistency in interpretation also argues against applying Section 7 Paragraph 2 of the KGG.
The plaintiff requests that
With the annulment of the resolution of the Association Assembly of 01.9.2016 and with the corresponding annulment of the appeal decision of the Kassel Savings Bank Association of 27.2016, the determination of the result of the seat allocation with regard to the election of the four members of the Administrative Board from the group of persons eligible to be elected to the City Council of the City of Kassel, which was carried out on 01.9.2016, is to be annulled.
The defendant requests that
to dismiss the lawsuit.
He argues that the lawsuit is inadmissible because it fails to demonstrate that the plaintiff's own rights have been violated. Regarding the merits of the case, he contends that there are no grounds for excluding Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the German Banking Act (KWG). According to Section 3 Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 of its statutes, the sponsoring organization of the "Kasseler Sparkasse" special-purpose savings bank is the savings bank association. This constitutes a special-purpose association within the meaning of the German Savings Banks Act (KGG). Section 7 Paragraph 2 of the KGG stipulates that the regulations applicable to municipalities apply mutatis mutandis to the special-purpose association, unless the KGG or the association's statutes provide otherwise. This is not the case here. Neither the Hessian Savings Banks Act (HSparkG) nor the KGG contains detailed regulations concerning the election procedure and the weighting of votes. Section 55 of the Hessian Municipal Code (HGO) applies mutatis mutandis to elections of savings bank supervisory boards. Neither Section 55 Paragraph 4 of the HGO nor Section 5b Paragraph 1 of the HSparkG prohibits the application of Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the KWG. If, as in this case, the Hessian Savings Bank Act (HSparkG) does not contain a provision, the general law applies, namely the Hessian Municipal Code (KGG) and the Hessian Municipal Code (HGO) with their references to the corresponding application of the Banking Act (KWG). The wording of Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the Banking Act (KWG) makes it clear that its provision merely specifies that of Section 22 Paragraph 3 of the Banking Act (KWG), and both paragraphs must be read as a single unit. The provision of Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the Banking Act (KWG) is specifically a regulation that applies to the election of administrative bodies and is therefore constitutionally unobjectionable, since independent administrative bodies are representative bodies of the people. The Kassel Administrative Court (VG Kassel) failed to recognize this in its decision of September 11, 2014 – 3 K 1133/12.KS – and also misinterpreted the cited decision of the Federal Constitutional Court (decision of August 8, 1994 – 2 BvR 184/94). The applicability of Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the Banking Act (KWG) follows from the fact that the election of the municipal administrative body must be carried out in accordance with Section 55 of the Hessian Municipal Code (HGO). The interpretation that, according to Section 5b Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 of the Hessian Savings Banks Act (HSparkG), only Section 22 Paragraph 3 of the Ordinance on the Organization of Municipal Savings Banks (KVVG) is applicable to the elections is clearly incorrect because the other paragraphs of Section 22 of the Banking Act also contain provisions that address regulatory needs for elections, particularly at municipal savings banks, without necessarily being substantively related to Section 22 Paragraph 3 of the Banking Act.
By decision dated December 27, 2016, the Kassel Savings Bank Association rejected the plaintiff's objection and addressed the plaintiff's objections in detail. The plaintiff made these objections the subject of his lawsuit on January 12, 2017 (date of receipt by the court).
By decision of 28 December 2018, the eight elected members of the Administrative Board of the Kassel Savings Bank were joined to the proceedings; Mr. Hermann Hartig took the “elected seat” of Christian Geselle, who had become a member of the Administrative Board ex officio in July 2017 through his election as Mayor of the City of Kassel, in the succession procedure.
For further details of the facts and the legal arguments, reference is made to the contents of the court file and the contents of the administrative file of the defendant savings bank association.
REASONS FOR DECISION
The court can decide on the claim despite the defendant's request at the end of the oral hearing for leave to file a written submission due to the change in the heading regarding the defendant's representative body, which occurred only the day before the oral hearing, because the defendant's authorized representative had also been granted power of attorney by the association's general meeting, had participated in the hearing without objection, and had submitted a substantive motion. Against this background, the need for consultation with the newly involved representative body is not apparent. The court therefore saw no reason to grant the request.
Furthermore, the proceedings cannot be partially discontinued. The plaintiff filed an election challenge, initially basing it on four arguments, but did not submit a specific written request. During the oral hearing, the plaintiff merely abandoned part of his argumentation, which is why this does not constitute a disguised partial withdrawal. Pursuant to Section 88 of the Administrative Court Procedure Act (VwGO), the court may not exceed the scope of the plaintiff's claim and must therefore decide on the final substantive request, which relates solely to the determination of the election results for the four members of the Administrative Board from among those eligible for election to the Kassel City Council.
The lawsuit is admissible.
As the addressee of the objection decision issued on December 27, 2016 as a substantive decision and as a member of the Zweckverband assembly who cast a vote in the election and himself ran for office (nomination of the Kasseler Linke faction), the plaintiff is entitled to bring an action pursuant to Section 42 Paragraph 2 of the Administrative Court Procedure Act (VwGO) and has in particular a legally protected interest in the correction of the seat allocation.
The plaintiff's objection, filed with the election officer on September 9, 2016, against the validity of the election, is to be interpreted as an appeal within the meaning of Section 7 Paragraph 2 of the Hessian Municipal Election Act (KGG) in conjunction with Sections 55 Paragraph 6 of the Hessian Municipal Code (HGO) and 68 Paragraph 1 of the Administrative Court Procedure Act (VwGO), and in particular was filed within the one-month period stipulated in Sections 55 Paragraph 6 Sentence 1 HGO and 70 VwGO. Since the present case does not involve direct elections by eligible voters, but rather indirect elections at a second stage, Section 55 Paragraph 6 HGO is the more specific provision compared to Section 25 of the Hessian Municipal Election Act (KWG) (see Hessian Administrative Court, Judgment of May 6, 2008 – 8 UE 746/17, regarding Section 55 Paragraph 3 HGO and joint nominations, para. 37 juris).
The claim, which is therefore admissible, is well-founded.
The determination of the result of the election of the four members of the Administrative Board from among those eligible to be elected to the City Council of the City of Kassel contradicts applicable law and must therefore be overturned (§§ 26 para. 3 no. 3, 31 para. 1 KWG).
According to Section 5b Paragraph 1 Sentence 3 of the HSparkG, the principles of proportional representation according to Hare-Niemeyer apply to the election of the members of the supervisory board by the representative body; Section 22 Paragraph 3 of the KWG applies accordingly.
The basic principle of the Hare-Niemeyer method is that the proportion of votes received corresponds to the proportion of seats won. The allocation of a "bonus seat" is rather foreign to the nature of this method. It actually favors smaller parties, which is why it can happen that, mathematically, a party or group of voters that receives more than half of all votes cast does not receive more than half of the seats to be allocated.
However, in the allocation of seats following the vote count, the so-called "majority clause" of Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the German Banking Act (KWG) was applied, contrary to legal requirements. As a result, the joint nomination of the SPD and Alliance 90/The Greens received three seats instead of two due to the absolute majority of votes received, and the drawing of lots for one seat between the AfD and the Kassel Left Party, as stipulated in Section 22 Paragraph 3 Sentence 4 of the KWG, was omitted. The provision of Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the KWG is not applicable to elections to the Administrative Board by the General Assembly of the Savings Bank Association. According to Section 5b Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 of the Hessian Savings Banks Act (HSparkG), the members of the Administrative Board pursuant to Section 5a Paragraph 1 Number 2 and Paragraph 2 Number 2 of the HSparkG (i.e., the eight additional expert members elected here) are elected for the duration of the term of office by the representative body of the sponsoring organization (the General Assembly of the Association) in accordance with the regulations applicable to the sponsoring organization (the savings bank association), unless otherwise specified below. However, the following sentence 3 stipulates that the principles of proportional representation according to Hare-Niemeyer apply to the election of the Administrative Board members by the representative body and that Section 22 Paragraph 3 of the German Banking Act (KWG) applies accordingly. According to the wording of Section 5b Paragraph 1 Sentence 3 of the HSparkG, only Paragraph 3 of Section 22 of the KWG, as a specific application of the Hare-Niemeyer method, is explicitly intended to apply to the proportional representation election, according to which the lottery procedure should have been carried out. Since Section 5b Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 of the HSparkG (Hamburg Savings Banks Act) permits the application of the regulations applicable to the sponsoring organization (the savings bank association), such as the KGG (Hamburg Savings Banks Act), the sponsoring organization's statutes, and, moreover, the regulations applicable to municipalities (Section 7 KGG), only insofar as nothing else is specified in the HSparkG, it is irrelevant that the application of Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the KWG (German Banking Act) is not expressly excluded. This follows by implication from the fact that only the corresponding application of Paragraph 3 of that section is expressly provided for.
While the provision in Section 22 of the German Banking Act (KWG) may be understood as a single unit, as the defendant argues, this unity is disrupted—a point the defendant overlooks—when other provisions, such as Section 5b Paragraph 1 Sentence 3 of the Hessian Savings Banks Act (HSparkG), expressly refer only to specific paragraphs or declare only specific provisions applicable. The freedom to impose such restrictions stems from the legislature's discretionary power.
Contrary to the defendant's view, this legal interpretation is not contradicted by the fact that Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the German Banking Act (KWG) specifies Section 22 Paragraph 3 KWG. Rather, the "majority clause" contained in Section 22 Paragraph 4 KWG, or its provision regarding the so-called "supplementary seat," constitutes a special rule for the case where, in the allocation of seats according to Paragraph 3, the electoral list of a party or group of voters that has received more than half of the votes of all electoral lists participating in the seat allocation does not receive more than half of the total seats to be allocated. Therefore, in relation to Section 22 Paragraph 3 KWG, it is not a supplementary rule, but an exception for the cases mentioned therein, which, as such, must be interpreted narrowly.
The legislative materials submitted to the court regarding the Hessian Savings Banks Act (HSparkG) do not indicate that Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the Banking Act (KWG) should apply in addition to Section 22 Paragraph 3. In particular, given that Section 5b Paragraph 1 Sentence 6 of the Hessian Savings Banks Act, in its version of February 24, 1991 (GVBl. I, p. 78), stipulated that if only one seat remained to be allocated due to identical maximum numbers, the decision would be made by drawing lots, it must be assumed that the amendment to Section 5b HSparkG of February 20, 1992 (see LT-Drs. 13/2127; GVBl. I, p. 189) was intended merely to simplify the wording of the law, and that the reference was therefore expressly intended only to the provision regarding the lottery procedure contained in Section 22 Paragraph 3 of the Banking Act (KWG). Moreover, Section 5b Paragraph 1 Sentence 3 HSparkG would be completely superfluous if, in addition to Section 22 Paragraph 3 KWG, Paragraph 4 of that section were also to apply.
Finally, the provision in Section 5b Paragraph 1 Sentence 3 of the Hessian Municipal Savings Act (HSparkG) cannot be interpreted in a manner consistent with the principle of equality of suffrage—i.e., in a corrective manner. Given that the legislature is fundamentally free in its choice of electoral system (see also Federal Constitutional Court, Judgment of July 25, 2012 – 2 BvE 9/11, para. 54 juris), applying Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the Municipal Election Act (KWG) via Section 5b Paragraph 1 Sentence 3 of the HSparkG is not constitutionally required. The joint list of candidates from the SPD and Alliance 90/The Greens received 26 of the 47 votes cast, or 55.32%. Applying Section 22 Paragraph 3 of the KWG would result in this list receiving two seats, or (only) 50% of the four seats to be allocated, due to the equality of the vote share with the seat share. Applying Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the Banking Act would, however, give the joint list of candidates from the SPD and Alliance 90/The Greens three seats, or 75% of the seats to be allocated. Neither alternative corresponds proportionally to the votes received, as the joint list would receive either more or fewer seats than its share of the vote would suggest.
The Federal Constitutional Court's chamber decision of August 8, 1994 (Case No. 2 BA 1484/94) does not lead to a contrary conclusion, as it essentially addresses only the imbalance in seat allocation—which must be accepted—in connection with the provision of Section 22 of the Thuringian Municipal Election Act (KWG), which is comparable to Section 22 of the KWG. It is simply within the legislature's discretion to choose among various systems of proportional representation (see also Wiesbaden Administrative Court, Judgment of June 20, 2002 – 3 E 1384/01, juris, headnote; Schmidt, in Bennemann et al., Hessian Municipal Constitutional Law, as of 2014, Section 22 KWG, para. 48 d), when the elections in question are not direct (first-level elections) but—as in this case—second-level elections.
The legislator has thus clearly defined its position in Section 5b Paragraph 1 Sentence 3 of the HSparkG and, aware of the shortcomings of the Hare-Niemeyer method with regard to the allocation of seats to electoral lists that achieve more than half of the votes but not more than half of the seats to be allocated, has nevertheless decided not to apply the "majority clause" (Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the KWG).
Since the determination of the election result regarding the election of the four members of the Administrative Board from among those eligible to be elected to the City Council of Kassel violates applicable law based on the above explanations, both the resolution of the General Assembly of the Kassel Savings Bank Association of September 1, 2016, concerning the allocation of seats, and the appeal decision of the Kassel Savings Bank Association of December 27, 2016—the latter to the corresponding extent—must be overturned.
The decision on costs is based on Section 154 Paragraph 1 of the Administrative Court Procedure Act (VwGO)
The decision regarding provisional enforceability is based on Section 167 of the Administrative Court Procedure Act (VwGO) in conjunction with Section 709 of the Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO).
The appeal is admitted due to the fundamental importance of the matter pursuant to Section 124 Paragraph 2 No. 3 of the Code of Administrative Court Procedure. The question of whether Section 22 Paragraph 4 of the Banking Act applies to the election of the members of the supervisory board by the representative body pursuant to Section 5a Paragraph 1 No. 2 and Paragraph 2 No. 2 of the Hessian Savings Banks Act has not yet been clarified by a higher court.
The following is information on legal remedies.


