1. Decisions of the Federal Social Court on social assistance (SGB XII)
1.1 – BSG, Judgment of July 18, 2019 (B 8 SO 13/18 R):
Guiding principle Dr. Manfred Hammel:
Expenses for the repair of eyeglasses are not to be financed from the standard allowance, but are to be recognized by the social welfare provider as a one-off need in accordance with § 31 para. 1 no. 3 SGB XII and provided "separately" by way of a mandatory decision.
Replacing eyeglass lenses is not a repair, but a new purchase that must be financed using standard needs allowances.
Replacing one or both lenses is not considered a repair if this procedure is medically indicated primarily for the purpose of adapting to a change in visual acuity. In this case, simply restoring the glasses to a functional state, i.e., repairing them by replacing the damaged lenses with the original prescription, is an unsuitable measure because it objectively lacks the capacity to compensate for the existing visual impairment.
If the purchase of new spectacle lenses is required based on a medical prescription, it must be assumed as a general rule that the provision of new spectacle lenses is essential due to the changed visual acuity, i.e., the costs for the new spectacle lenses must be covered from the standard allowance – possibly by taking out a loan (§ 37 para. 1 SGB XII).
2. Decisions of the State Social Courts on basic income support for job seekers (SGB II)
2.1 – LSG Lower Saxony-Bremen, decision of 18 September 2019 (L 15 AS 200/19 B ER):
Guiding principle Dr. Manfred Hammel
: Rejection of granting a subsidy for the purchase of a car or a loan for this purpose to secure and maintain the apprenticeship from funds of the placement budget (§ 16 para. 1 sentence 2 SGB II in conjunction with § 44 SGB III) or by way of free funding (§ 16 f SGB II), because it can be considered quite possible and reasonable to cover the 5.5 km distance to the nearest train station by bicycle, even on days when work has to be done until 8 p.m. or in individual cases even until 10 p.m.
Even during the winter months and after 8 p.m., it is possible and reasonable for adult benefit recipients who are not affected by serious health problems to travel a distance of less than 10 km by bicycle once or twice a day.
Note:
Further information: Cycling distances of less than 10 km are considered reasonable for recipients of Hartz IV benefits
: www.juris.de
2.2 – State Social Court of Saxony-Anhalt, decision of 19 June 2019 – L 2 AS 150/19 B ER and L 2 AS 151/19 B – legally binding
Self-employment as a scrap metal dealer – requirements for demonstrating a permanent right of residence
No right of residence as a self-employed EU citizen entitled to freedom of movement.
Guiding principle (Editor)
: Requirements for substantiating the duration of habitual residence for the claim under Section 7 Paragraph 1 Sentence 4 SGB II.
Source: socialcourtsability.de
Note:
Principle (Juris)
1. On the requirements for the design of an activity as a self-employed Union citizen established (here: scrap dealer/collector) through the actual possibility of using a motor vehicle and the corresponding right of use when stating that it is used for collecting with the vehicle.
2. On the effects of a permit to use a vehicle registered in Bulgaria without any evidence of its actual use.
3. Decisions of the social courts on basic income support for job seekers (SGB II)
3.1 – SG Wiesbaden, judgment of August 16, 2019 – S 5 AS 811/16
"Gambler" must repay Hartz IV benefits.
Guiding principle (Editor):
A Hartz IV recipient who sells his house due to gambling debts, thereby bringing about his own need for assistance, must repay Hartz IV benefits received.
Source: socialcourtsability.de
4. Decisions of the State Social Courts and Social Courts on Social Assistance (SGB XII)
4.1 – Baden-Württemberg State Social Court, Judgment of 25 September 2019 – L 7 SO 4766/17
Principle (Juris)
1. Income within the meaning of Section 82 Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 of the German Social Code, Book XII (SGB XII) includes everything that someone receives in the form of money or in kind during the period of need. For the question of whether income exists, it is generally irrelevant what type of receipts they are, where they come from, whether they have a legal basis, how they were paid, and whether and to what extent the receipts are taxable under the Income Tax Act.
2. A private occupational disability pension can constitute income of the insured person if the occupational disability insurance concluded by the (different person) policyholder constitutes insurance for the account of another within the meaning of Section 43 Paragraph 1 of the German Insurance Contract Act (VVG), so that the rights arising from this insurance contract belong to the insured (Section 44 Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 VVG).
Source: socialcourtsability.de
5. Miscellaneous information on Hartz IV, social assistance, asylum law, housing benefit law and other legal codes
5.1 – Note on: BSG 11th Senate, Judgment of 27 June 2019 – B 11 AL 14/18 R
Author: Dr. Thomas Sommer, Chairman of the Judges' Court
Contentious issue: waiting period for refusing work and information on legal consequences
Guiding principle for the note
on the requirements for a notification of legal consequences in the case of a waiting period for refusal of work with a duration of six or twelve weeks.
Continue on Juris
5.2 – Working aid “Social rights for refugees – The Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act”, by Kerstin Becker
Advisor for Refugee Aid/Policy
Department of Migration and International Cooperation
The Paritätische Gesamtverband
Due to the extensive legal changes to the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act, which came into force on August 21 and September 1, 2019, we are sending you a short guide to the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act. This is a partial pre-publication of our comprehensive guide "Social Rights for Refugees," which is scheduled to be published in its third edition later this fall. In particular, the numerous sanctions related to receiving social benefits are discussed in detail.
We sincerely thank the author, Claudius Voigt from GGUA Münster, for developing this working aid!
You can find the working aid here: www.der-paritaetische.de
Author of the legal news ticker: Detlef Brock, editor of Tacheles
Source: Tacheles legal case law ticker


