1. Decisions of the state social courts on basic income support/citizen's allowance (SGB II)
1.1 – Saxon State Social Court, decision of 03.01.2024 – L 4 AS 567/23 B ER
Citizen's income/basic income support:
Punishing citizen's income recipients for their behavior is not the purpose of Section 5 Paragraph 3 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II), according to the association Tacheles.
Because a request for cooperation from the Job Center (in this case, to apply for child supplement at the Family Benefits Office) must specify the concrete action required and the specific reaction intended by the authority in the event of a lack of cooperation.
1. The withdrawal of benefits to secure subsistence requires a discretionary decision; otherwise, the decision is unlawful.
Citizen's allowance:
Notices of withdrawal issued by the Job Center due to lack of cooperation are often unlawful because of a lack of discretionary power.
Guiding principles
1. The instruction on legal consequences required under Section 5 Paragraph 3 Sentence 4 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) is subject to the same strict requirements as the written notification of the legal consequences of failure to cooperate provided for in Section 66 Paragraph 3 of the German Social Code, Book I (SGB I).
2. In any case, the scope of the refusal or withdrawal pursuant to Section 5 Paragraph 3 Sentence 3 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) requires a discretionary decision by the respondent (see Saxon State Social Court, decision of 06.01.2023 – L 7 AS 591/22 B ER – juris Rn. 31).
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
Legal tip from Tacheles e. V.:
see also Saxon State Social Court, decision of 06.01.2023 – L 7 AS 591/22 B ER –
The withdrawal of citizen's allowance after failure to provide benefits from another provider requires a discretionary decision that takes into account the right to benefit reductions.
I would like to refer to the following statement by a judge of a social court:
" Every tax-funded 'customer advisor' of every tax-funded 'job center' can be expected to offer their royal 'customers ' ' customer meetings' in an appreciative tone when necessary and to solicit their cooperation in a benevolent manner. "
1.2 – Saxon State Social Court, Judgment of 17.08.2023 – L 3 AS 458/22
Guiding principles
1. The assignment of an employable person entitled to benefits by the job center is a prerequisite for the granting of a subsidy to the employer in accordance with Section 16i Paragraph 1 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II).
2. The allocation notice pursuant to Section 16i Paragraph 3 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) is an administrative act.
3. The assignment does not create a legal relationship between the benefit recipient and the employer. It is a special form of job placement, a specific placement offer from the SGB II benefits provider.
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
1.3 – LSG Hessen, Judgment of 13.12.2023 – L 6 AS 305/23 – Appeal allowed
Basic income support/citizen's allowance:
On the question of whether the regulation in Section 37 Paragraph 2 Sentence 2 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) is a time limit regulation.
While the Federal Social Court (BSG) held the view that Section 37 Paragraph 2 Sentence 2 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) in its former version was not a time limit regulation (BSG, Judgment of January 18, 2011 – B 4 AS 99/10 R), it expressly left this question open for the newly worded regulation Section 37 Paragraph 2 Sentence 2 of the German Social Code, Book II (BSG, Judgment of July 11, 2019 – B 14 AS 51/18 R).
LSG Hessen:
Can an application for citizen's allowance submitted by email on August 1st be considered an application for benefits from July 1st?
No, it does not have retroactive effect to July 1, 2021. The benefit begins on August 1.
1. No retroactive effect on citizen's income – benefits under the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) are not provided for periods prior to the application (Tacheles e. V.)
Guiding principles:
In addition to the wording of Section 37 Paragraph 1 Sentence 1, Paragraph 2 Sentences 1 and 2 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II), the systematic structure of the provision also argues against a retroactive effect of an application for benefits beyond the first of the month.
It is irrelevant whether Section 37 Paragraph 2 Sentence 2 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) constitutes a statutory deadline. In any case, Section 26 Paragraph 3 of the German Social Code, Book X (SGB X) does not apply, but is superseded by the specific provision of Section 37 Paragraph 2 Sentence 2 of the SGB II.
Source: www.rv.hessenrecht.hessen.de
1.4 – LSG BB, Judgment of 18.10.2023 – L 4 AS 1273/20 – Appeal allowed
Citizen's income – income consideration and adjustment – educational support benefits – school fees as a tax deduction
Tuition fees for attending a private school or educational institution that charges fees are not an expense related to generating income, because they are not contingent on generating income (Tacheles e. V.).
Citizen's income:
School fees are not considered as business expenses for BAföG recipients (guideline editor of Tacheles e. V.)
Guiding principles:
Tuition fees for attending a fee-based private educational institution are not expenses related to receiving BAföG benefits because they are not contingent on generating income.
Source: www.gesetze.berlin.de
Legal tip from Tacheles e. V.:
Contrary to this ruling: Hamburg Higher Social Court, decision of June 18, 2019 - L 4 AS 155/19 B ER; Berlin-Brandenburg Higher Social Court, judgment of March 6, 2008 – L 28 AS 1276/07
1.5 – LSG Baden-Württemberg, judgment from July 18, 2023 – L 9 AS 2972/20
Guiding principles
1. A review decision pursuant to Section 44 Paragraph 1 of the German Social Code, Book X (SGB X) does not become the subject of the proceedings concerning the original decision pursuant to Section 96 of the German Social Courts Act (SGG).
2. Lactose or fructose intolerance does not, in principle, justify an additional need within the meaning of Section 21 Paragraph 5 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II).
3. Costs for healthcare for medically necessary preparations not covered by the statutory health insurance benefits do not, in principle, constitute an unavoidable additional need under Section 21 Paragraph 6 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II). The entitlement to subsistence is primarily covered in this respect by membership in the statutory health insurance system.
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
Legal tip from Tacheles e. V.:
Reimbursement for such health-related additional needs under Section 21 Paragraph 6 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) is only possible if, before and during the start of the relevant treatment or purchase of various care products, there was a sufficient reason for the intervention in question, i.e., an indication existed that can be comprehensibly established based on medical documentation (Lower Saxony-Bremen State Social Court, Judgment of January 10, 2019 – L 15 AS 262/16; Bavarian State Social Court, Decision of March 9, 2017 – L 7 AS 167/17 B ER; Hamburg State Social Court, Judgment of March 19, 2015 – L 4 AS 390/10).
Note from the Tacheles association:
The plaintiff was completely unprepared. To file a claim for additional health-related expenses, one must be extremely well prepared!
The following should be provided:
1. A medical certificate or report confirming the illness, which must show that the necessary care supplies are urgently needed to avoid health impairments.
2. It must be precisely documented what was purchased (receipts, etc.).
3. An application should be submitted to the health insurance company, but a rejection will come promptly. However, this is needed for the court proceedings.
4. In case of intolerance to some care products (this often occurs), this should be medically substantiated.
5. A cost breakdown to prove need for assistance is advisable (compare the healthcare allowance in the social welfare office (currently approx. €21.50) with the costs of non-prescription medications). Section 21 Paragraph 6 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) does not specify an absolute de minimis threshold. There is a good chance of success if medically necessary!
6. For a hardship allowance pursuant to Section 21 Paragraph 6 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II), the individual case must be considered, focusing on the need that is objectively unavoidable in this life situation. Because the burden increases with the duration of the additional need, it must also be taken into account whether this need is expected to arise in the short, medium, or long term.
1.6 – LSG Schleswig-Holstein, Decision of 14.12.2023 – L 6 AS 127/23 B ER
Regarding the assumption of rent arrears in the case of (even) timely termination of the lease, an article by attorney Helge Hildebrandt
01.02.2024
If recipients of citizen's allowance under the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) have rent arrears, these can be covered by the job center according to Section 22, Paragraph 8 of the SGB II. A prerequisite is that the assumption of the debt is "justified" to secure the housing. The debt must be covered if it is necessary to prevent eviction. Eviction is imminent at the latest when the landlord has terminated the lease due to rent arrears or has already filed for eviction.
More information: www.hempels-sh.de
2. Decisions of the social courts on citizen's income (SGB II)
no
3. Decisions of the State Social Courts on Employment Promotion Law (SGB III)
3.1 – LSG Hamburg, judgment of November 22, 2023 – L 2 AL 18/21
Requirements for proof of notification of an administrative act – evidence – free evaluation of evidence
Guiding principle
1. The provision in Section 37 Paragraph 2 of the German Social Code, Book Ten (SGB X) is based on the principle of experience that a sent notification will also be received. If receipt is disputed, its notification can be based on circumstantial evidence and carried out by way of free evaluation of the evidence. (Paragraph 28)
2. If the recipient of a decision has not responded to any reminder or enforcement measure stating that the authority's claim was unknown to them, but on the contrary has made payments towards the claim, then it is to be assumed that the contested decision has been served. (Paragraph 30)
Source: www.landesrecht-hamburg.de
4. Decisions of the State Social Courts on Social Assistance (SGB XII)
4.1 – Social Court Munich, decision of 08.08.2023 – S 46 SO 266/23 ER
Basic income support benefits for the elderly and those with reduced earning capacity:
1. Approval period of less than six months is possible (Tacheles e. V.)
2. The fact that continuous bank statements result from a lawful limitation of the approval period to three months is not objectionable (Tacheles e. V.)
Guiding Principles:
In preliminary injunction proceedings, an authority cannot, in principle, be compelled by the court to issue an administrative act due to the prohibition against prejudging the main issue. The approval period for basic income support for the elderly and those with reduced earning capacity can also be less than six months if there is a corresponding objective justification.
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
5. Decisions on asylum law and the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG)
5.1 – LSG Hamburg, judgment of 10/05/2023 – L 4 AY 1/21
Conditions for a hospital's claim for reimbursement against the social welfare provider under Section 6a AsylbLG
Principle
1. The hospital's entitlement to reimbursement of hospital treatment costs by the social welfare agency under Section 6a of the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG) requires, among other things, the existence of an emergency. Such an emergency is precluded if the social welfare agency is on call at the time of patient admission. Furthermore, the reimbursement claim must be asserted within a reasonable period. This period is one month. (Paragraph 24)
2. A claim for reimbursement of the hospital's expenses arising from a public-law contractual relationship is excluded. The patient's admission to the hospital is not in the interest of the social welfare agency. (Paragraph 25)
Source: www.landesrecht-hamburg.de
6. Miscellaneous information on citizen's income, social assistance, asylum law, housing benefit law and other legal codes
6.1 – LSG Berlin-Brandenburg: Assumption of rent arrears in cases of unreasonably high accommodation costs (copyright protection must be observed)
Editorial team eGovPraxis Jobcenter:
Can the job center provide a loan to cover rent arrears for an unreasonably expensive apartment? What conditions must be met? The Berlin-Brandenburg Higher Social Court (LSG) had to address this question.
Conclusion:
The assumption of rent arrears as a loan is justified, among other things, only if the costs of the accommodation to be secured are within the reasonable limits of Section 22 Paragraph 1 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II).
Securing long-term accommodation that is not cost-effective is generally not justified.
Avoiding a change of school during a school year is not sufficient to justify the assumption of rent arrears for an unsuitable apartment.
The decision as to whether the apartment is worth preserving depends on the forecast of whether the beneficiaries can cover the amount of rent not covered by the job center and will use their income for this purpose.
Source: Decision of the Berlin-Brandenburg Higher Social Court of 23 August 2023 – L 31 AS 627/23 B ER
Recommended reading from Tacheles e. V.:
Rent arrears loans are possible in individual cases even with unreasonably expensive accommodation, article by attorney Matthias Göbe, Berlin (please note copyright protection), mentioned in the Tacheles case law ticker week 28/2023
Continue reading at www.anwalt.de
Important note:
Unpublished judgments (marked with "nv"), annotations, and case reviews by lawyers that we receive from courts, lawyers, or private clients may be quoted, but only with attribution to Verein Tacheles. Anything else constitutes copyright infringement.
Thank you!
The information, guidelines and legal tips in the ticker must also be marked with the source: "Information from Tacheles", anything else constitutes a copyright infringement.
This publication is subject to the Creative Commons CC-BY-SA 3.0 license.
Any use of copyrighted works on the internet without the consent of the author or rights holder constitutes copyright infringement. Quotes from the ticker always require attribution!
Author of the case law ticker: Tacheles editor Detlef Brock.
Source: Tacheles case law ticker


