1. Decisions of the Federal Social Court on social assistance (SGB XII)
1.1 – BSG, judgment of 12/18/2024 – B 8 SO 1/24 R –
Regarding the consideration of official negligence in the exercise of discretion within the framework of the revocation of an unlawful favorable administrative act pursuant to Section 45 Paragraph 2 Sentence 3 of the German Social Code, Book X (SGB X).
Federal Social Court (BSG): Reimbursement notice from the social welfare agency unlawful in case of administrative error
Consideration of the authority's fault in the exercise of discretion must be taken into account in reimbursement decisions issued by the social welfare agency.
Even if the plaintiff received the benefits unlawfully for years, the following must apply according to the opinion of the 8th Senate of the Federal Social Court
The exercise of discretion required for the reimbursement proves to be flawed.
This is because the payments of benefits are based on the failure of the case worker at the authority to remove a checkmark in the computer application and on a lack of internal control mechanisms over a period of more than four years.
This serious administrative error should have been taken into account in the discretionary assessment under Section 50 Paragraph 2 in conjunction with Section 45 of the German Social Code, Book X (SGB X), regarding reimbursement.
This error of discretion alone renders the reimbursement administrative act unlawful.
Conclusion:
Official negligence must regularly be taken into account as a relevant factor in the discretionary decision on the revocation of a favorable administrative act pursuant to Section 45 Paragraph 2 Sentence 3 of the German Social Code, Book X (SGB X), even if it is not a gross error.
Source: www.bsg.bund.de
2. Decisions of the State Social Courts on Citizen's Allowance (SGB II)
2.1 – LSG BB, judgment of 08/15/2024 – L 20 AS 1438/21-
SGB II: Job Center must pay ALG II as a supplement despite co-ownership share (issued in relation to Hartz IV)
Guidelines www.berlin.de
If two co-owners of a residential building use the rooms of the building separately and do not form a community of need within the meaning of Section 7 Paragraph 3 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) or a household community within the meaning of Section 9 Paragraph 5 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II), then, when examining the appropriateness of the building within the meaning of Section 12 Paragraph 3 No. 4 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) (old version), only the living space corresponding to the respective share of co-ownership is to be taken into account.
2.2 – LSG Baden-Württemberg, decision of 04.09.2024 – L 12 AS 2547/24 ER-B –
Citizen's income: No preliminary legal protection with an account balance of €34,315.49
A recipient of citizen's income is not entitled to the issuance of an interim injunction due to a lack of entitlement to an injunction if he has a bank balance of €34,315.49 and also has free access to the account.
Source. www.socialcourtsability.de
3. Decisions of the social courts on citizen's income (SGB II)
3.1 – none
4. Decisions of the State Social Courts on Employment Promotion Law (SGB III)
4.1 – SG Freiburg, decision of 19.08.2024 – S 15 AL 2084/24 ER –
Unemployment benefits: No subsequent cancellation of unemployment benefits if the prognosis regarding ability to work changes
If the Federal Employment Agency changes its assessment of a benefit recipient's employability after issuing a decision granting unemployment benefits, this alone does not constitute a significant change within the meaning of Section 48 of the German Social Code, Book X (SGB X) and therefore does not justify the revocation of benefit decisions (guiding principle by Detlef Brock).
A subsequent change of opinion does not constitute a material change within the meaning of Section 48 Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 of the German Social Code, Book X (SGB X) and therefore does not justify the revocation of the grant notice (LSG Baden-Württemberg, Judgment of 14 March 2008 – L 8 AL 1601/07; LSG Bayern, Judgment of 21 June 2018 – L 9 AL 27/16 -).
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
5. Decisions of the State Social Courts and Social Courts on Social Assistance (SGB XII)
5.1 – LSG Baden-Württemberg, Decision of 18 November 2024 – L 2 SO 730/24 – www.sozialgerichtsbarkeit.de
Social assistance: No social assistance benefits will be granted for clothing during preventive detention
This is because the prison maintains an extensive stock of clothing in its clothing room and generally provides inmates with new clothing if they are in need.
The financial resources available to the plaintiff, which according to his own statements amount to approximately €125 in pocket money and €75 for food per month, are sufficient to purchase his own (new) clothing if necessary, should the clothing provided by the institution be insufficient or not to his liking. No shortfall in his needs is apparent in this respect.
If the relevant legal provisions of the Baden-Württemberg Prison Act (JVollzGB V BW) or the potentially burdensome or rejected measures issued on its basis should infringe upon the plaintiff's rights, the debtor of this claim is not the defendant as the social welfare provider, but the enforcement authority, against which legal protection pursuant to Section 83 of the Baden-Württemberg Prison Act (JVollzGB V BW) can be obtained from the enforcement chambers of the ordinary courts in accordance with Sections 109 to 121b of the Prison Act (StVollzG) (see also the decision of the Berlin-Brandenburg Higher Social Court of 03.09.2009 – L 15 SO 41/09 B PKH -).
Practical advice
LSG BW, judgment of 18.04.2024 – L 7 SO 376/24 –
Social assistance: No entitlement to clothing and initial furnishings for prisoners
Those serving a life sentence in a correctional facility (JVA) are not entitled to clothing and initial furnishings from the social welfare provider (§§ 31 and 67 SGB XII).
The social welfare provider does not have to pay for one-off needs such as clothing or initial furnishings for inmates if the correctional facility provides clothing and furniture (guideline Detlef Brock).
6. Decisions on asylum law and the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG)
6.1 – SG Heilbronn – Decision of 29.11.2024 – S 16 AY 2391/24 ER –
Keywords: Section 3 Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG), Section 3a AsylbLG, Section 86b Paragraph 2 Sentence 2 Social Court Act (SGG), initial reception center, benefits under Section 3 AsylbLG, benefits under Section 3a AsylbLG, standard benefit level 1
Granting of benefits pursuant to Section 3a Paragraph 1 No. 1 and Paragraph 2 No. 1 of the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG) in preliminary legal protection proceedings
Source: Attorney Sven Adam
6.2 – SG Fulda – Decision of 28 November 2024 – S 7 AY 6/24 ER
Legal norms: Section 1a Paragraph 4 Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG), Section 45 Social Code Book X (SGB X) – Keywords: Social court expedited proceedings, benefit reduction, discretionary decision, Fulda Social Court
AsylbLG: If the authority revokes a benefit award notice regarding the amount of benefits under Section 45 SGB X for a person entitled to transfer payments, the benefit provider must also be aware that it has discretion to exercise (here denied).
According to Section 39 Paragraph 1 Sentence 2 of the German Social Code, Book I (SGB I), there is a right to the proper exercise of discretion.
Source: Attorney Sven Adam
We wish all readers a happy new year 2025
Author of the case law ticker: Tacheles editor Detlef Brock.
Source: Tacheles case law ticker


