Tacheles Legal Case Law Ticker Week 14/2025

1. Decisions of the Federal Social Court on basic income support under the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) - Citizen's Allowance

1.1 – BSG, judgment of 11/28/2024 – B 4 AS 16/23 R – www.socialgerichtsbaren.de

Basic income support for job seekers – consideration and calculation of income – income from operating a photovoltaic system – feed-in tariff – assets – income

BSG: Profits from the operation of a photovoltaic system must be considered as income

Guiding principle Detlef Brock
1. Profits from the operation of a photovoltaic system must be taken into account as income for the purposes of basic income support under the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II).

2. No deduction of earned income allowances, because it is not income from employment.

3. The feed-in tariff constitutes income to be taken into account within the meaning of Section 11 Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II). Only the €30 insurance allowance is deductible.

4. The Federal Social Court (BSG) left open the question of whether the PV system is even an asset protected under the scope of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II).

5. The plaintiffs' fundamental rights do not preclude considering the feed-in tariff as income and disregarding the employment allowances.

In particular, the fundamental right to a dignified minimum standard of living under Article 1 Paragraph 1 in conjunction with Article 20 Paragraph 1 of the Basic Law (see, fundamentally, the Federal Constitutional Court decision of 9 February 2010 – 1 BvL 1/09 et al. – BVerfGE 125, 175 = SozR 44200 § 20 No. 12) is not violated.

2. Decisions of the social courts on citizen's income (SGB II)

2.1 – SG Konstanz, Judgment of 20.04.2024 – S 10 AS 245/23 –

Failure to consider the interest rate on a private loan as accommodation costs for owner-occupied residential property – the agreement between the father (recipient of assistance) and his 3 children does not withstand an arm's-length comparison

Citizen's income: Interest payments from a private loan are not considered housing costs

Guiding principle Detlef Brock
1. A citizen's allowance recipient has no entitlement to the assumption of further accommodation costs amounting to €150.00 per month as interest payments for a loan granted to him by his children.

2. Because a regulation concerning the specific repayment modalities is a basic requirement for a loan that can be taken into account under Section 22 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II).

3. Furthermore, no proof of the proper use of the alleged loan amount has been provided.

4. A significant defect is already evident in the fact that a written form, as is customary in business transactions, does not exist, since there are no written loan agreements for the total sum of €150,000.00 and no agreement on repayment.

5. It was not possible in this case to assume the payments of €50.00 per month made by the recipient of benefits to his three children as part of the housing costs, since it was not possible to classify the payments either as interest, as claimed by the plaintiff, or as repayments, due to the lack of regulations in the loan agreements that existed according to the plaintiff's submissions.

There are also doubts as to whether a loan agreement intended for the implementation of a specific purpose was actually concluded.

Practical tip:
Hamburg Higher Social Court, judgment of 9 September 2021 – L 4 AS 279/20 – subsequently Federal Social Court, 9 June 2023, B 7/14 AS 87/21 R, other resolution: withdrawal

Interest payments for a private loan taken out at a later date – in addition to the financing loan for an owner-occupied apartment – ​​cannot be considered as accommodation needs within the meaning of Section 22 Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II), if the private loan serves neither the acquisition nor the maintenance of the accommodation, but rather the financing of the repayment installments of the original real estate loan.

Comment by Detlef Brock:
I do not agree with this finding by the judge of the 10th Chamber of the Social Court of Konstanz, who ruled that loan agreements require written form.

The Federal Social Court, in its judgment of June 17, 2010 – B 14 AS 46/09 R – ruled on loans from relatives – repayment obligation – requirements for proof as follows:

1. According to the Federal Social Court (BSG), it is not necessary that both the structure (e.g., written form, interest agreement, or provision of collateral) and the implementation of the agreement must correspond in every respect to what is customary between strangers – especially with a credit institution.

For such a separate requirement, in addition to the civil law requirements (as a further condition of the offense), arises neither from the law nor from or in conjunction with general principles.

Rather, the restrictions on contract design associated with the strict arm's length principle for loan agreements, which, incidentally, is only applied to certain categories of cases in the case law of the Federal Fiscal Court, would do justice neither to the actual circumstances nor to the fundamentally required respect for familial relationships of trust.

In this sense, many state social courts and, most recently, the Social Court of Karlsruhe, judgment of 29.10.2024 – S 12 AS 1592/23 – have also ruled accordingly

1. It is not necessary that both the structure (e.g., written form, interest agreement, or provision of collateral) and the implementation of the agreement must correspond in every respect to what is customary between unrelated parties – in particular with a credit institution (referring to BSG, judgment of 17.06.2010 – B 14 AS 46/09 R -).

2.2 – SG Reutlingen, decision of 25.04.20218 – S 7 AS 179/18 –

Social law – Withdrawal of benefits due to breach of cooperation obligations – Illegality in coercing information irrelevant to the current claim

Guiding principle Detlef Brock
1. Job centers may not use refusal – or withdrawal notices – to recipients of citizen's income as a penal provision with subsequent sanctions.

Principle www.sozialgerichtsbarkeit.de
1. A withdrawal of ongoing benefits by the authority based on § 66 SGB 1 is unlawful if the conditions for entitlement to benefits exist even without the requested information from the person concerned.

2. Section 66 of the German Social Code, Book 1 (SGB 1) is not a penal provision that can be used to sanction the omission of other information.

Decision prepared and researched by Detlef Brock: www.gegen-hartz.de

2.3 – SG Kassel – Judgment of 28.03.2025 – S 8 AS 313/22 –

Citizen's income: Court criticizes job center for outdated cost-cutting request

Court criticizes job center – because no reduction in housing costs is granted in the case of an outdated cost reduction request.

Guiding principle Detlef Brock
1. According to the case law of the Federal Social Court (BSG), later concepts cannot be used as subsequent reasons for past cost reduction proceedings, according to the judges of the 8th Chamber in Kassel, referring to BSG, judgment of 30 January 2019 – B 14 AS 11/18 R –.

2. A new cost reduction request is required if the job center determines and bases its calculations on new appropriateness values.

3. Outdated cost-cutting requests do not trigger the 6-month period of the job center.

4. In the absence of a request to reduce costs, a recipient of citizen's income is entitled to have costs taken into account in the amount of the current values ​​according to the housing benefit table plus a safety margin.

5. This was already the ruling of the Social Court of Kassel of 13 June 2024 – S 14 AS 97/22 –.

www.gegen-hartz.de

In a new ruling, the Social Court of Kassel has just announced a decision regarding the costs of accommodation for recipients of citizen's income (case number: S 8 AS 313/22)

Guiding principle Detlef Brock
1. In the absence of a request to reduce costs, the citizen's allowance recipient is entitled to consideration of costs at least in the amount of the current values ​​according to the housing allowance table plus a safety margin.

2. To avoid unnecessary repetition, the court refers to the decision of the 14th Chamber of the Social Court of Kassel of June 13, 2024, file number: S 14 AS 97/22, where it stated the following:

3. In the Court's view, in light of this, there is no room to consider only the appropriate values.

4. The Jobcenter's assertion that the concept for determining reasonable costs will be decisive from January 1, 2020, is unhelpful. This is only relevant if reasonable costs can be considered at all. This is not the case due to the lack of cost reductions.

Conclusion:
Reduction of housing costs is not possible with an outdated cost reduction request.

3. Decisions of the State Social Courts on Employment Promotion Law (SGB III)

3.1 – LSG BW, Decision of 25.03.2025 – L 12 AL 514/25 ER-B –

Unemployment benefits: Benefits for participation in working life in expedited proceedings only if discretion is reduced to zero, here denied

Guiding principle Detlef Brock
1. No granting of benefits for participation in working life in expedited proceedings, because even within the framework of the preliminary legal protection procedure, except in cases of a reduction of discretion to zero, the authority must be left with some leeway to exercise the discretion imposed upon it (see LSG Saxony-Anhalt, decision of 07.07.2011, L 5 AS 177/11 B ER).

2. If the conditions for entitlement are met, there is indeed a legal entitlement to the special benefits under Section 117 of the German Social Code, Book III (SGB III), however, the respondent has discretion regarding the type of support and the service provider (State Social Court [LSG] Rhineland-Palatinate, judgment of 27 October 2016, L 1 AL 52/15).

3. A special feature of discretionary benefits is that, in a constitutionally permissible manner, the law does not prescribe a specific legal consequence for the administration when the substantive requirements are met in a particular case. In these cases, applicants only have a right to the proper exercise of discretion under Section 39 of the German Social Code, Book I (SGB I), but not to a specific benefit.

4. A right to the sole possible lawful decision exists only if discretion can be exercised lawfully in one specific way and any other decision would be unlawful. However, a so-called "reduction of discretion to zero" only occurs if, based on the established facts, any other decision-making process is legally impossible.

5. In principle, even within the framework of preliminary legal protection proceedings, except in cases where discretion is reduced to zero, the authority must be left with some leeway to exercise the discretion imposed upon it (see LSG Saxony-Anhalt, decision of 07.07.2011, L 5 AS 177/11 B ER).

4. Decisions of the State Social Courts and Social Courts on Social Assistance (SGB XII)

4.1 – LSG BW, Judgment of 27 February 2025 – L 7 SO 804/24 – Appeal – not admitted – www.sozialgerichtsbarkeit.de

Social assistance: Section 19 Paragraph 6 of the German Social Code, Book XII (SGB XII) does not cover outpatient services provided by nursing care services (see also Higher Social Court of North Rhine-Westphalia, judgment of October 28, 2024 – L 20 SO 362/22 – appeal pending before the Federal Social Court – B 8 SO 1/25 R –; contra Higher Social Court of North Rhine-Westphalia, judgment of September 19, 2024 – L 9 SO 16/22 – Federal Social Court – B 8 SO 13/24 R (pending))

Guiding principle Detlef Brock
1. Outpatient service providers are not facilities within the meaning of Section 19 Paragraph 6 of the German Social Code, Book XII (SGB XII), and cannot be equated with them with regard to the transfer of claims. Section 19 Paragraph 6 of the SGB XII also does not apply to outpatient nursing services that essentially provide 24/7 care to recipients of benefits under the SGB XII in shared living arrangements.

2. Section 19 Paragraph 6 of the German Social Code, Book XII (SGB XII) cannot be applied analogously to providers of care services who are not institutions. By limiting its application to services provided in institutions (or care allowance), the provision establishes clear factual boundaries; anything exceeding these boundaries is expressly not intended to be covered by the statutory transfer of the provision and therefore does not constitute a regulatory gap – which would be essential for an analogous application.

3. As an exception to the general principle of the non-inheritability of (highly personal) social assistance claims (cf. Deckers in Grube/Wahrendorf/Flint, SGB XII, 8th edition 2024, § 19 para. 22 with further references), the provision is not subject to analogous application (similarly, LSG North Rhine-Westphalia, judgment of October 28, 2024 – L 20 SO 362/22 –).

4.2 – Social Court Freiburg, Decision of 21 March 2025 – S 7 SO 411/25 ER – www.sozialgerichtsbarkeit.de

Social assistance – basic income support for the elderly and those with reduced earning capacity – accommodation and heating – unreasonable accommodation costs – expiry of the waiting period – possibility and reasonableness of cost reduction

Social assistance: After 30 years, a severely disabled person over 65 years of age is evicted or abruptly removed from her apartment

Guidance by Detlef Brock
1. Elderly sick social assistance recipient – ​​Benefit recipient loses fight against the court despite health problems

2. After 30 years, the elderly lady must vacate her unsuitable apartment, as she must also look for accommodation in surrounding communities (BSG case law).

Guiding Principles www.sozialgerichtsbarkeit.de
1. If, pursuant to Section 86a Paragraph 2 No. 5 of the Social Courts Act (SGG), the immediate enforceability of an administrative act is ordered by the authority, but the administrative act is later replaced by another administrative act, the order of immediate enforceability does not continue to apply to the replacing administrative act unless the authority expressly orders immediate enforceability of the replacing administrative act as well.

2. An application for an order suspending the effect of an objection or an action against a benefit decision linked to an order of immediate enforceability is to be interpreted as an application for a determination of the suspensive effect of the objection or action in accordance with Section 86b Paragraph 1 No. 2 of the Social Court Act (SGG), insofar as the original benefit decision has been replaced by amending decisions pursuant to Section 86 of the Social Court Act (SGG) or Section 96 of the Social Court Act (SGG), which in turn do not contain an express order of immediate enforcement.

3. If a recipient of benefits under Chapter 3 or 4 of the German Social Code, Book XII (SGB XII) is subject to the obligation under Section 35 Paragraph 2 of the SGB XII to reduce his unreasonable housing costs, he is, in principle, to be referred to the entire local area of ​​responsibility of the benefit provider when searching for housing – in accordance with the case law of the Federal Social Court on the parallel provision Section 22 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II).

4. If the benefit recipient wishes to limit their housing search to a specific municipality or another sub-area within the local jurisdiction of the benefit provider and claims a particular social connection to their current place of residence, they must explain the basis of this connection in each individual case (e.g., relatives or friends in the immediate vicinity, mutual support within the neighborhood, volunteer work in the local area). Simply referring to a long period of residence in the current place of residence (here: 30 years) is not sufficient.

5. If a recipient of benefits over the age of 65 under Chapters 3 or 4 of the German Social Code, Book XII (SGB XII), lacks internet usage skills, a device with internet access, or any other means of internet access, their cost-reduction efforts under Section 35 Paragraph 2 of the SGB XII are not insufficient simply because they did not include online housing offers in their search. This is because online housing searches do not (yet) reflect the predominant lifestyle habits of their age group, and the housing market is not generally closed to individuals without internet access or experience.

6. The expiry of a waiting period pursuant to Section 35 Paragraph 3 Sentence 1 of the German Social Code, Book XII (SGB XII) constitutes a significant change in the legal circumstances pursuant to Section 48 Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 of the German Social Code, Book X (SGB X). This entitles the benefit provider, even during an ongoing benefit period under Chapters 3 and 4 of the SGB X, to amend the calculation of benefits for housing and heating costs for the future, provided that reducing housing costs by the end of the waiting period was neither impossible nor unreasonable. This is because, after the expiry of the waiting period pursuant to Section 35 Paragraph 3 Sentence 1 of the SGB XII, benefits for housing and heating costs are granted according to a different legal standard of review than during the waiting period.

Comment by Detlef Brock
: Does the case law of the Federal Social Court no longer apply to older people regarding accommodation costs? (Case No. B 8 SO 24/08 R)

A truly terrible decision by the court, because you don't transplant older trees!!

Especially since the Federal Social Court (BSG) had ruled on accommodation costs for elderly people in 2010 as follows:

BSG, Judgment of 23.03.2010 – B 8 SO 24/08 R –
If elderly people live in an apartment that is somewhat too expensive and paid for by the social welfare office, they cannot generally be required to move.

Experience shows that the activity radius of older people decreases, so that housing and living environment become increasingly important for the physical and mental well-being of the elderly (Second Report on the Situation of the Older Generation in the Federal Republic of Germany: Housing in Old Age, 1998, BT-Drucks 13/9750, p. 17).

Since the aging process is accompanied by a decrease in adaptability and an increase in susceptibility to disease, older people are typically less mobile than the average population (Federal Report on the Elderly 1998, pp. 93 and 198).

These sociological findings must (in principle) also be taken into account when assessing the (subjective) reasonableness of moving to another apartment.

However, this does not apply without exception and without taking into account all the circumstances of the individual case.

When assessing the reasonableness of a move to reduce the housing costs of elderly people receiving basic income support in old age, their right to remain in their long-established and familiar social environment must be given special consideration, according to the Federal Social Court (BSG) in its judgment of March 23, 2010 – B 8 SO 24/08 R – concerning housing costs for elderly people receiving basic income support, Chapter 4 of the German Social Code, Book XII (SGB XII).

What applies to citizen's income?
Here too, a long period of residence is not a reason that could make the move unreasonable in the sense of the jurisprudence of the Federal Social Court.

Finally, the length of residence, the age of the plaintiffs and their continued presence in the social environment are not decisive reasons (cf. BSG, judgment of April 13, 2011 – B 14 AS 32/09 R –) that can preclude a move.

The “maintenance of the social environment”, an “affective attachment” to a particular district or an age of, for example, 56 years do not preclude a move (BSG, judgment of April 13, 2011 – B 14 AS 106/10 R – and BSG, judgment of December 17, 2009 – B 4 AS 27/09 R –).

Reasons that may also preclude a move, such as illness, disability, need for care, consideration for school-age children, or single parenthood, may argue against the concrete appropriateness of the lower, abstractly appropriate accommodation requirement and the reasonableness of cost-cutting measures (BSG of 19.2.2009 – B 4 AS 30/08 R – and BSG, judgment of 16.04.2013 – B 14 AS 28/12 R -).

5. Decisions on asylum law and the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG)

5.1 – LSG Bayern, decision of 10.03.2025 – L 11 AY 58/24 B ER –

Guiding principles www.sozialgerichtsbarkeit.de
The restriction of benefits pursuant to Section 1a Paragraph 4 Sentence 2 of the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG) in individual cases where protection is granted by another Member State is not unconstitutional without the existence of further unwritten elements of the offense (here, the reasonableness of returning to the Member State granting protection) and, in the case of abusive entry, probably also does not violate Union law due to the lack of applicant status.

5.2 – Social Court Karlsruhe, Decision of 31 March 2025 – S 12 AY 706/25 ER – www.sozialgerichtsbarkeit.de

Karlsruhe judge condemns asylum seeker benefits agency – accusation of enrichment at the expense of others – outrageous decision – My utmost respect for this judge

1. In the specific case where, in response to a circular from the Ministry of Justice and Migration of Baden-Württemberg, the local lower reception authority responsible for refugees intentionally defrauds a refugee in order to reduce official expenses, so that instead of the "benefits in case of illness" to be granted at the expense of the federal state under the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG), he chooses the so-called "compulsory follow-up insurance" under the German Social Code, Book V (SGB V), at the expense of the statutory health insurance fund, even though this puts the refugee himself in a contribution debt trap and damages the assets of the insured community of the chosen statutory health insurance fund due to the insolvent contribution debtor.

2. An authority acting in bad faith is bound by its intentionally incomplete written information just as it would be bound by a legally binding assurance if the authority intended to fraudulently enrich itself by providing misleading information and thereby knowingly harm the assets of third parties and cause the deceived person to become financially indebted.

3. Anyone who, with the intention of obtaining an unlawful financial advantage for himself or a third party, damages the property of another by creating or maintaining an error through the misrepresentation of false facts or the distortion or suppression of true facts, shall be punished with imprisonment for up to five years or with a fine.

Guiding principles www.sozialgerichtsbarkeit.de
1. The amount of €3.50 obviously does not cover the daily subsistence minimum of an adult single person in the Federal Republic of Germany in 2025.

2. According to Section 6 Paragraph 1 of the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG), refugees may claim other benefits from the agencies responsible for administering asylum seekers' benefits as long as they are awaiting a decision from the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees on their asylum application and, in individual cases, are subject to minimum contribution obligations to statutory health insurance under Section 188 Paragraph 4 of the German Social Code, Book V (SGB V) or to long-term care insurance under Section 20 Paragraph 3 of the German Social Code, Book XI (SGB XI) due to the termination of their employment under social security law.

3. An authority is bound in good faith by promises that are not legally binding but are nevertheless insinuated through incomplete proactive information if it intends to enrich itself through fraudulent conduct, damage the assets of third parties and cause the deceived party to suffer economic hardship.

4. The obligation to comply with law and justice is no more at the free disposal of the people seeking refuge in Baden-Württemberg from persecution in their home country than it is of the authorities responsible for their reception, including the Ministry of Justice and Migration to which they are subordinate.

Practical tip:
See also the note from the legal representative, attorney Sven Adam:

The Social Court of Karlsruhe, in a decision dated March 31, 2025, under file number S 12 AY 706/25 ER, in expedited proceedings seeking a preliminary injunction, provisionally ordered the State of Baden-Württemberg, represented by the Rastatt District Office, to assume the health and long-term care insurance contributions of the mandatory follow-up insurance pursuant to Section 6 of the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG).

6. Miscellaneous information on citizen's income, social assistance, housing allowance and other legal codes

6.1 – LSG Bayern, Costs decision of 25.02.2025 – L 12 RF 23/24 –

The cost of a Germany-wide ticket for travel to the court hearing must be reimbursed if it is less expensive than a single ticket. The applicant is entitled to reimbursement of travel expenses totaling €54.60 pursuant to Section 5 of the German Judicial Remuneration and Compensation Act (JVEG).

Guiding principles www.sozialgerichtsbarkeit.de:
More expensive weekly or monthly tickets are generally not objectively necessary for attending court hearings. Therefore, a partial reimbursement of costs or a reimbursement of the hypothetical cost of a single ticket is not possible.

A full or partial refund of the costs for a Germany ticket that is regularly available (subscription, purchase already made for another trip) is not possible.

However, a different rule applies if the Germany ticket was purchased for the journey to the court hearing, because it incurs lower costs than a single ticket.

Important note:
Unpublished judgments (marked with "nv"), annotations, and case reviews by lawyers that we receive from courts, lawyers, or private clients may be quoted, but only with attribution to Verein Tacheles. Anything else constitutes copyright infringement.
Thank you!

The information, guidelines and legal tips in the ticker must also be marked with the source: "Information from Tacheles", anything else constitutes a copyright infringement.

This publication is subject to the Creative Commons CC-BY-SA 3.0 license.

Any use of copyrighted works on the internet without the consent of the author or rights holder constitutes copyright infringement. Quotes from the ticker always require attribution!

Author of the case law ticker: Tacheles editor Detlef Brock.
Source: Tacheles case law ticker