Overview of case law – basic income support, social assistance, Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG) and citizen's income
As of March 1, 2026.
Editor: Detlef Brock.
Publisher: Tacheles Legal News Ticker
1. Decisions of the Federal Social Court on basic income support under the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II).
1.1 – BSG, Judgment of 02.12.2025 – B 7 AS 6/25 R –
Subject:
Constitutionality of the level of standard benefit according to standard benefit level 2 in 2022
Decision:
The Federal Social Court was not convinced that the amount of the standard benefit according to standard benefit level 2 for the year 2022 was unconstitutionally low.
Key finding:
There is no violation of Article 1 Paragraph 1 in conjunction with Article 20 Paragraph 1 of the Basic Law. Fundamental rights other than Article 1 Paragraph 1 in conjunction with Article 20 Paragraph 1 of the Basic Law cannot, in principle, establish further standards for determining the amount of benefits to secure subsistence (Federal Constitutional Court, judgment of February 9, 2010 – 1 BvL 1/09 –).
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
2. Decisions of the state social courts on basic income support under the German Social Code, Book II (citizen's allowance)
2.1 – LSG Baden-Württemberg, decision of 22.01.2026 – L 13 AS 159/26 ER-B –
Subject:
On the assumption of costs for the extension or renewal of the passenger transport license in preliminary injunction proceedings.
Decision:
The court rejected the job center's claim for reimbursement of costs. This is because, in preliminary injunction proceedings, when a benefit is sought whose granting is at the discretion of the authority, a claim for an injunction can only be accepted if it is credibly demonstrated that this discretion is reduced to zero. The applicant failed to provide such credible evidence in this case. Furthermore, it is not apparent that renewing the passenger transport license is the only way to reduce or alleviate the applicant's need for assistance within the meaning of Section 9 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II).
Key messages:
- According to Section 16 Paragraph 1 Sentence 2 Number 2 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II), employable persons in need of assistance may be entitled to benefits for activation and vocational integration in accordance with Section Two of the German Social Code, Book III (SGB III). The subsidies that can be provided from the placement budget pursuant to Section 44 of the SGB III may, in principle, also cover costs for a passenger transport license.
- However, benefits under Section 16 Paragraph 1 Sentence 2 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) are at the discretion of the basic income support provider ("may").
- If, in preliminary injunction proceedings, a claim is made for a benefit whose granting is at the discretion of the authority, a claim for an injunction can only be accepted if it is credibly demonstrated that the discretion is reduced to zero.
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
2.2 – LSG Baden-Württemberg, decision of 20.01.2026 – L 13 AS 3/26 ER-B –
Subject:
Benefit recipient seeks measure according to § 16k SGB II (holistic support) in preliminary legal protection.
Decision:
The Social Court found that, with regard to the requested measure under Section 16k Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II), neither a claim to an order nor grounds for an order had been substantiated. Furthermore, the Senate points out that assigning a measure by way of preliminary legal protection would also constitute an inadmissible prejudgment of the main issue.
Key messages:
- The basic income support provider has discretion in its selection, i.e., the design of the assistance is generally left to it, which is why the assignment of a specific measure to a specific measure provider is not an option.
- Recipients of citizen's income generally have no right to be assigned to a specific measure or to a specific measure provider.
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
2.3 – LSG Hessen, decision of 05.02.2026 – L 6 AS 559/25 B –
Topic:
Legal recourse in the case of transfer of claims according to § 33 SGB II
Principle:
Section 33 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) constitutes a purely authorizing provision for corresponding private-law actions by the authority. The resulting private-law actions of the defendant are not subject to recourse to the social courts pursuant to Section 51 of the German Social Courts Act (SGG).
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
Legal note:
Bavarian State Social Court, decision of 5 November 2012 – L 7 AS 493/12 B PKH –
2.4 – LSG Berlin-Brandenburg, Judgment of 27 January 2026 – L 1 AS 1363/25 B ER –
Subject:
Rejection notices from the job center (§ 66 SGB I) can generally only apply from now on (ex nunc).
Decision:
The 1st Senate of the LSG Berlin-Brandenburg is of the fundamental opinion, in accordance with the literature and case law on the SGB II, that refusal notices by the basic income support provider can never apply retrospectively.
Key messages:
- The withdrawal of benefits takes effect exclusively from the present moment and may only be pronounced to that extent. A withdrawal retroactive to the point in time when the obligation to cooperate arose cannot, from the outset, be lawfully based on Section 66 of the German Social Code, Book I (SGB I).
- The withdrawal of benefits pursuant to Section 66 of the German Social Code, Book I (SGB I), does not prevent the accrual of an entitlement to benefits or the existence of a subjective right to benefits. Rather, the entitlements to benefits cease from the moment the withdrawal decision becomes effective, that is, prospectively for the duration of the withdrawal decision. No other legal basis is applicable in this respect.
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
Legal note:
The refusal of benefits under Section 66 of the German Social Code, Book I (SGB I) is not aimed at the annulment of a previous benefit award or at a reduction of benefits (Hesse Higher Social Court, decision of July 20, 2011 – L 7 AS 52/11 B ER –).
2.5 – LSG Munich, decision of 06.02.2023 – L 16 AS 18/23 B ER –
Topic:
Citizen's income as a grant or loan in the case of an inheritance of €2–2.5 million
Decision:
The court is of the opinion that the plaintiff should be granted the citizen's allowance, including her rent costs, as a subsidy, because she was unable to utilize the inheritance during the grant period.
Key messages:
- Job center demands liquidation of assets through inheritance sale – unlawful, says the court. If, for example, a property cannot be sold or encumbered at all during the benefit period due to encumbrances, then it is considered permanently unusable, with the consequence that benefits must be paid not only as a loan but as a grant.
- The job center's reference to theoretically possible uses is not sufficient.
Guiding principles:
- For benefits to be granted in the form of a loan, it is not sufficient that the applicant possesses assets if it is not foreseeable whether they can derive any economic benefit from those assets. A general unusability within the meaning of Section 12 Paragraph 1 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II), exists if it is uncertain when a condition necessary for the assets to be used will be met.
- If a property is not expected to be saleable or encumbered during the approval period, it is considered permanently unusable. In such cases, benefits must be provided as a grant.
- Job centers also have advisory and informational obligations under Section 9 Paragraph 4 and Section 24 Paragraph 5 of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II).
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
3. Decisions of the social courts on basic income support / citizen's allowance
3.1 – SG Braunschweig, Judgment of 12.12.2025 – S 44 AS 295/23 –
Topic:
Benefits under the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) as a grant instead of a loan
Decision:
Social Court Braunschweig: Supplementary Citizen's Allowance Despite Inheritance Community and €100,000 in Assets.
The court granted the applicant supplementary benefits because the conditions of Section 12 Paragraph 1 Sentence 2 Number 5, or alternatively Number 7, of the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II) were met. This is because other types of housing rights are also protected, such as leasehold rights (Federal Social Court, Judgment of March 24, 2015 – B 8 SO 12/14 R –) or rights of residence. It is sufficient that the property is attributed to the individual's assets. Such an attribution exists here, given the registration in the land register as a member of the inheritance community.
Furthermore, a division of the inheritance cannot be demanded because this would constitute a particular hardship for the plaintiff, Section 12 Paragraph 1 Sentence 2 Number 7 SGB II, for example, due to family reasons.
Key messages:
- A claim for partition of an inheritance under Section 2024 of the German Civil Code (BGB) cannot be enforced if the "appropriate" house property is occupied by the owner. This also applies even if the plaintiff is not the sole owner of the house property, but rather ownership is transferred to him through his share in the community of heirs, of which he is registered as a member in the land register.
- Insofar as case law has held that a claim for the settlement of an inheritance under Section 2024 of the German Civil Code (BGB) can also be utilized, this has exclusively concerned cases in which the plaintiffs did not live on the property in question themselves or in which the property was unprotected due to its living space.
- A settlement of the inheritance cannot be demanded also because this would constitute a particular hardship for the plaintiff, § 12 para. 1 sentence 2 number 7 SGB II. A particular hardship is always to be assumed if the realization of the assets would not enable the plaintiff to support himself with the proceeds from the realization.
- In addition, exceptional hardship can also be justified by extraordinary circumstances that do not regularly occur in other benefit recipients and, in their interaction, cast the case in a particularly egregious light. Family circumstances, in particular, can lead to an exemption from asset requirements due to exceptional circumstances, as is the case here.
Source: SG Braunschweig
Legal note:
Lower Saxony-Bremen State Social Court, judgment of 08.07.2011 – L 9 AS 524/07 –
4. Decisions on employment promotion law (SGB III)
4.1 – LSG Hamburg, Judgment of 10 November 2025 – L 2 AL 6/24 –
Subject:
No entitlement to unemployment benefit I due to lack of personal unemployment registration
Decision:
The court finds that the applicant is not entitled to unemployment benefit I retroactively because the requirement of personal registration as unemployed with the responsible employment agency is not met.
Key messages:
- A notification to the job center is not sufficient for this.
- Registering as unemployed with another authority does not, in principle, create an entitlement to benefits. Section 16 Paragraph 2 of the German Social Code, Book I (SGB I) and Section 28 of the German Social Code, Book X (SGB X) apply only to applications, not to the requirement of registering as unemployed for entitlement to benefits.
- The registration of unemployment is a notification of a fact and not a declaration of intent and therefore has an independent, different meaning than an application (reference to Öndül in: Schlegel/Voelzke, jurisPK-SGB III, 3rd edition, § 141 SGB III [as of 04.01.2024], para. 44).
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
Legal note:
Hamburg Higher Social Court, judgment of 09.02.2022 – L 2 AL 27/21 –
No entitlement to unemployment benefit I, because registering as unemployed with the Jobcenter team.arbeit.hamburg is not sufficient.
5. Decisions on social assistance (SGB XII)
5.1 – LSG Lower Saxony-Bremen, Judgment of 15 May 2025 – L 8 SO 81/23 –
Topic:
On the assumption of funeral costs by the social welfare office and the relationship to state law on funeral arrangements and the reasonableness of bearing the costs.
Decision:
The 8th Senate of the Lower Saxony-Bremen State Social Court (LSG) ruled that the mother was not entitled to reimbursement of her deceased son's funeral expenses because these expenses were deemed reasonable for her within the meaning of Section 74 of the German Social Code, Book XII (SGB XII). The mother had not attempted to recover the money from the deceased's daughters. Therefore, any existing doubts regarding the unreasonableness of her bearing the funeral expenses were resolved against the plaintiff, who bore the burden of proof.
Key messages:
- No reimbursement of funeral expenses without a serious attempt to enforce the claim through civil law (based on LSG Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, case no. L 9 SO 18/18).
- A referral by the social welfare office to potential compensation claims is exceptionally possible if the applicant in need of assistance generally refuses to make their own efforts to realize compensation claims, even though claims can easily be realized (cf. BSG of 29.09.2009 – B 8 SO 23/08 R –).
- A person who is only secondarily obligated under the burial laws of the federal states can be obligated within the meaning of Section 74 of the German Social Code, Book XII (SGB XII). Section 74 SGB XII does not contain a principle that only a person with primary obligation under state law may assert claims for the assumption or reimbursement of costs.
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
Note by Detlef Brock:
It is completely controversial in jurisprudence and literature whether a person who is secondarily obligated under the burial laws of the federal states can be obligated within the meaning of § 74 SGB XII (for example, LSG Baden-Württemberg, judgment of 25.04.2013 – L 7 SO 5656/11 –).
Case law references:
LSG Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, judgment of 10 March 2022 – L 9 SO 12/19 –
and judgment of 2 May 2024 – L 9 SO 18/19 –
5.2 – SG Augsburg, Judgment of 27.01.2026 – S 3 SO 96/24 –
Topic:
Assistance services alongside outpatient supported living for people with Trisomy 21 (Down syndrome)
Decision:
The court is of the opinion that the plaintiff is entitled to integration assistance in the form of support services for personal future planning (PZP) in addition to supported living. The court is of the opinion that the services provided and to be provided by the residential group are no longer sufficient to enable the plaintiff to develop a sufficiently concrete future perspective (§ 78 SGB IX).
Key messages:
- According to Section 113 Paragraph 1 of the German Social Code, Book IX (SGB IX), social participation benefits are provided to enable or facilitate equal participation in community life.
- According to Section 113 Paragraph 2 Number 2 of the German Social Code, Book IX (SGB IX), participation benefits also include, in particular, assistance services. The entitlement is further specified in Section 78 Paragraph 1 Sentence 2 of the SGB IX, which specifically includes services related to personal life planning as an assistance service.
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
6. Decisions concerning the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG)
6.1 – SG Karlsruhe, decision of 10.02.2026 – S 12 AY 392/26 ER –
Subject:
Entitlement to preliminary legal protection for the provisional granting of standard benefit level 1 in reception facilities
Decision:
- The 12th Chamber concludes that the special needs level applied so far by the authority pursuant to Section 3a Paragraph 1 No. 2 lit. b) AsylbLG and Section 3a Paragraph 2 No. 2 lit. b) AsylbLG is unconstitutional.
- According to Section 3a Paragraph 4 Sentence 1 of the Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act (AsylbLG) in conjunction with Section 28a of the Social Code Book XII (SGB XII), the monthly benefits for needs level 1 will continue to amount to €460 per month in 2026.
Key messages:
- The grandfathering clause of Section 28a Paragraph 5 SGB XII also applies in the calendar year 2026 via the reference in Section 3a Paragraph 4 Sentence 1 AsylbLG.
- A social court thwarts access to effective interim legal protection in matters of subsistence if it makes the issuance of a preliminary regulatory order subject to excessively high substantiation requirements.
Guiding principles:
- If a person affected by economic hardship has credibly demonstrated, in light of their personal and economic circumstances, a current entitlement to subsistence benefits (under the German Social Code, Book II, Book XII, or Asylum Seekers' Benefits Act), there is generally no reasonable basis for requiring them to additionally demonstrate, in order for the issuance of a preliminary injunction, that they also face individual and concrete "significant disadvantages" within the meaning of Section 86b Paragraph 2 Sentence 2 of the German Social Courts Act (SGG) while awaiting (judicial) main proceedings (contra Burkiczak in: Schlegel/Voelzke, jurisPK-SGG, 2nd ed., Section 86b SGG [as of January 30, 2026], para. 475; Higher Social Court of Baden-Württemberg, August 28, 2019, L 7 AY 2735/19 ER-B; Higher Social Court of Baden-Württemberg). 13.02.2020 – L 7 AY 4273/19 ER-B; LSG North Rhine-Westphalia, 21.02.2022, L 12 AS 1846/21 B ER; LSG Baden-Württemberg, 04.04.2023, L 7 AY 335/23 ER-B; LSG Hesse, 01.06.2023, L 4 SO 41/23 B ER; LSG Baden-Württemberg, 31.10.2023, L 3 AS 2391/23 ER-B; LSG Baden-Württemberg, 23.02.2024, L 3 AS 261/24 ER-B).
- In 2026, asylum seekers entitled to benefits can also claim the standard benefit rates determined for the calendar year 2024 of standard benefit level 1 if they are accommodated in reception facilities within the meaning of Section 44 Paragraph 1 of the Asylum Act or in communal accommodations within the meaning of Section 53 Paragraph 1 of the Asylum Act.
Source: www.socialgerichtsabilities.de
7. Miscellaneous
7.1 – SG Karlsruhe, Judgment of 19.02.2026 – S 9 KG 2096/25 –
Topic:
Child benefit according to the Federal Child Benefit Act (BKGG) for anonymously/confidentially born children
Decision:
The court unequivocally concludes that children born anonymously/confidentially are generally entitled to child benefits under social security law, as they are considered equivalent to orphans due to the lack of knowledge of their biological parents. The same applies if the child is left in a baby hatch.
Guiding principles:
- Only the counselor at the advice center who verifies the child's origin knows the pregnant woman's actual name and checks her identity. However, this counselor, as a professional bound by confidentiality under Section 53 Paragraph 1 Sentence 1 No. 3a of the German Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO), is subject to a right to refuse to testify.
- The decisive factor is whether the court can determine the identity of the child's mother (in this case, denied). It is irrelevant that the child could only learn the identity of its mother under certain conditions from the age of 16 at the earliest.
7.2 – Schleswig Administrative Court, Judgment of 13 February 2026 (Case No. 15 A 71/23)
Topic:
Long-term students are not entitled to housing benefit / rent subsidy
Decision:
No housing benefit entitlement for students pursuing their studies as a hobby. Anyone who has completed their 68th semester of study is not entitled to housing benefit under Section 21 No. 2 of the Housing Benefit Act (WoGG). According to this section, no entitlement exists for those who do not pursue their studies seriously and purposefully.
Note on citation style
Unpublished judgments or comments may only be quoted with attribution to the source:
- Source: Tacheles Case Law Ticker Week XX/2025 – Author: Detlef Brock
- Newsletter: Thomé Newsletter 12/2025 from April 6th, 2025 - Author: Harald Thomé
- License: Creative Commons CC BY-SA 3.0
Quotations without source attribution are a violation of copyright law.
Author: Detlef Brock, editor of Tacheles.
Source: Tacheles legal news ticker, week 9/2026


